History books may record the first copyright act in the world, as the Statute of Anne, dating back to a 1710 English law, but in Ireland we attribute the concept of copyright law to an old feud between two famous Irish saints.
Colmcille, the great and honored saint of Donegal and Ulster plays a pivotal role in this first copyright dispute. He admired a book which was written by another famous saint of Ireland, St. Finnian.
Saint Colmcille
Colmcille believed this book should be copied to make its contents available to a wider public audience. St. Finnian disagreed and denied Colmcille permission to copy his work.
Now, being a man, and a Donegal man into the bargain, Colmcille did not like to take “no” for an answer. He secretly copied the book. To illuminate the dark room in which he worked he set the five fingertips of his left hand ablaze (Donegal finger-lighting boys are not to be toyed with).
A young boy was attracted by the supernatural lights radiating from the church. He spied on the plagiarizing saint through a small hole in the church door. Alack and alas, Colmcille was guarded by none other than his pet crane. The bird stuck his beak through the hole, plucking out the boy’s eye.
The injured youth beat a path to St. Finnian’s door, in sheer anguish. The saint miraculously restored the eye, but was none too happy when he learned what the bold Colmcille was up to.
Finnian argued with Colmcille, disputing his assumed right to copy his precious work. Unable to reach a concensus they turned to Diarmaid, the High King, to resolve the issue.
After careful deliberation the High King reached his verdict, coining the famous phrase:
“To every cow her calf; to every book its copy.”
Sample page from the Book of Kells – an ancient Irish manuscript
Books were then made of vellum which is stretched and dried calf skin. The word vellum comes from the French word ‘vel’ meaning calf.
This declaration was the very first copyright judgement in history.
Colmcille wasn’t one bit pleased with this verdict, so he waged war on the High King. Although he emerged triumphant in battle, he never assumed the role of King. He was banished to Scotland, forced into exile as punishment for his sins.
And so, all writers and artists worldwide who benefit from the ever-so-important legal protection of copyright law can thank the Irish for its inception.
Many may believe this tale to be mere legend, not a verifiable historical fact. Even so, we Irish hate to “let the truth get in the way of a good story”. Therefore we are taking full credit for the origins of copyrighting.
Slán agus beannacht,
(Goodbye and blessings)
Irish American Mom
Have never heard this before, Mairead — love it! Also love how the Irish don’t want to let truth get in the way of a good story 🙂
Cheryl – I think “not letting the truth get in the way of a good story,” may have been the motto for many of these old Irish legends.
I agree with you, a great story! Interesting about vellum, the origin of the word. I learn so much from your blog! xx
Kay – I love all these old Irish legends and myths. When I was growing up my Mom would tell us these stories and read the tales of Finn MacCool and other Irish legendary heroes to us. Thanks for stopping by.
Mairead
All legend is based on truth, and all Irish truths are legendary,
Cheers,
Brian.
What a great way to put it Brian. So true!
A good story teaches as much as a well written history and more because it excited a search for more stories. Good history starts there because it encourages research and a love of all things of the past including the stories that tell of the peoples who shared them.
A true History Buff
Very well said, Chris. Stories are as much a part of history as the facts.